HANSARD
SITTING CALENDAR
SEARCH
LIVE BROADCAST
Hansard Dynamic Subject Index
Legislative Council - Fifty-First Parliament, Second Session (51-2)
2008-02-13 Daily Xml
Contents
Pdf Xml

Ministerial Statement

STOLEN GENERATIONS

The Hon. P. HOLLOWAY (Minister for Police, Minister for Mineral Resources Development, Minister for Urban Development and Planning) (14:21): A few moments ago the Premier made a statement in relation to the national apology to the Stolen Generation. I seek leave to read that statement to the council.

Leave granted.

The Hon. P. HOLLOWAY: Before I read the statement, I note that today is the second anniversary of the passing of the Hon. Terry Roberts, a former member of this place and minister for Aboriginal affairs and reconciliation in this government. Of course, he was a person who was deeply committed to the advancement of the indigenous people of this country. The Premier's statement is as follows:

First of all, I want to acknowledge that we in this parliament meet today on the traditional lands of the Kaurna people and that we respect their spiritual relationship with their country. I am sure that all of us are proud that the Aboriginal flag, the South Australian flag, and the Australian flag fly side by side above us.

Today's apology by the Prime Minister and by the national parliament marks a momentous occasion in the history of this nation. It heralds, we all hope, the beginning of a respectful new relationship between indigenous and non-indigenous Australians. In that spirit, I offer the warmest welcome and acknowledgement to the elders, to members of the stolen generations, and family members from Aboriginal communities across South Australia who join us in this parliament today.

This morning in Elder Park, I sat alongside Aboriginal elders and joined with other South Australians from every possible background to watch the Prime Minister deliver his national apology to the stolen generations. In Canberra, the Minister for Aboriginal Affairs and Reconciliation (Jay Weatherill), and our newly appointed Commissioner for Aboriginal Engagement, Klynton Wanganeen, were among the thousands present to witness this landmark address.

Across the nation, I am sure there are millions of people who, like me, were proud to be Australian this morning when, at last, we were united as a people in acknowledging the injustices of the past as we move forward towards reconciliation.

In South Australia it is fair to say that we have been here before, perhaps in a smaller way. But from little things, big things grow. Nearly 11 years ago, in this place, on a day like this, our opposing parties were not opposed, even on matters of detail or wording. We were bigger than that, and we then apologised wholeheartedly and unanimously. There were no dissenting or discordant voices. We said sorry for wrongs done in our time, and in years before our time, to the first custodians of this ancient land.

On that day, we made a belated effort towards healing, or at least to try to make amends, or to find sufficient words of consolation, sadness, regret and sympathy for wrongs and cruelties, as well as the honest mistakes that could now not be undone. On that day, in this parliament there were no weasel words. We were not afraid to apologise; we were not afraid to say sorry, and I join with the Prime Minister in doing so again.

So today, but now as Premier, I too, say sorry. These words had to be said clearly and unequivocally in this parliament, and now, today, with decency, grace, candour and feeling, from a national parliament and a new prime minister. Words that herald a new beginning.

On 28 May 1997, this parliament was one the first in Australia to express its deep and sincere regret to the stolen generations for the impact of past government policies on Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities, and on our state and nation. The motion was passed without dissent. I still believe it was one of the best days in the history of this parliament.

The Aboriginal affairs minister at the time, the Hon. Dean Brown, for whom I have a great respect—

I know they are the Premier's words, but I endorse them—

recognised the needs of political unity. He said:

Reconciliation has nothing to do with party politics: it is about the future of Australia. Today, this parliament, on behalf of the people of South Australia, takes another important step along the road towards reconciliation.

Our apology that day offered a chance for members on both sides of this house to recognise the pain endured by so many Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander families and communities. Seconding Dean Brown's motion, I spoke of mothers at settlements around Australia desperately trying to hide and, in some cases, temporarily bury their children in order to prevent them from being taken away.

In 1991, at Ooldea, as minister for Aboriginal affairs I had the privilege of handing over the title of the Ooldea lands to Maralinga elders who had confronted everything, even the testing of nuclear weapons on their lands and the poison left behind. We had a ceremony in the desert and elders cooked dinner for us at our campsite the night before. Trucks and cars arrived from all directions and Aboriginal people, both young and old, walked with us to a place where, for thousands of years, Aboriginal people had lived and gathered next to a precious water source. In more recent times it had become the site of Daisy Bates' mission. Today there are still a few pepper trees that mark the mission site amongst the sandhills. And beneath those sandhills—land sacred to Aboriginal people—is one of the richest and oldest archaeological sites in the world.

But it was also a place where so many Aboriginal children had been taken away from their parents. Towards the end of the ceremony I was approached by an elderly Aboriginal woman weeping and in considerable distress. Her son told me that she had been taken away from her mother at Ooldea and, in later life, had spent years trying to trace and meet her family and the mother she never knew. I was told that she eventually met her mother before she died. But she was so proud and so moved on that day that she had finally returned to her birthplace. She had finally come back to the place from which she had been taken. Her mother's little girl had finally come home. And she had done so on the very day, at the very moment, that Ooldea land had once again been recognised as Aboriginal land.

I have attended lands rights ceremonies where Aboriginal women have poignantly sung about the babies being taken away. They were singing about their own experiences, and each time their song was followed by a prolonged, painful silence. It is a grief that has not healed. Others in this chamber on that date tried to imagine the suffering in order to empathise with those whose lives were torn apart. The then member for Napier, Annette Hurley, said, 'As a mother I know how I would feel if my child were taken away from me and I never knew what happened to that child all through its life.'

All who spoke acknowledged that the practices undertaken in the past have an ongoing impact within the Aboriginal community. The premier of the time, John Olsen, noted, 'The decisions which led to this sad episode have caused a scar on the face of the nation.' The ceremonies that I have attended; the grieving I have witnessed, seem to embody that scar, that stain on our soul to which the Prime Minister referred earlier today.

Back in 1997 we agreed to learn from these past mistakes. The apology to the Stolen Generations was symbolic, but it was also sincere. Here in South Australia we took our first step down the road to reconciliation. Today's apology in our federal parliament represents another critically important milestone in that journey. Some people, of course, have dismissed symbolic acts just as they dismissed land rights. They said they preferred practical remedies. But you cannot have one without the other.

Beyond these words there is a long, hard road to travel. Many here will not see its end. But today is at least a beginning. And, in the spirit of South Australia's apology more than a decade ago, I look forward to working with the opposition and all members of this parliament towards the day when the First Australians are no longer the last Australians in health, education, employment, life expectancy and opportunity.

Today the Prime Minister also spoke of practical outcomes. Past experience has shown us that practical outcomes cannot be reached without a respectful partnership and an acknowledgement of past injustices. Since coming to office in 2002 my government has used the apology delivered in this house in 1997 as a platform to pursue recognition, justice and healing for the Aboriginal people. In 2004 I was proud to honour a pledge I had made years before to return a large area of land, the Mamungari Conservation Park, to the ownership of the Maralinga Tjarutja and Pila Nguru Aboriginal people. It was the biggest hand back of land in 20 years.

More recently, we have worked with the Anangu Pitjantjatjara Yankunytjatjara people in our state's north-west to try to solve problems such as petrol sniffing. We are acting in partnership with Aboriginal people to try to find solutions to the most difficult problems. There is now a new school, swimming pools, a power station, rehabilitation centre, bush tucker programs and arts centres, as well as police back on the lands.

But there is much, much more to be done, and we welcome the pledge of a new era of cooperation from the Prime Minister—cooperation with the states and with the opposition and, most importantly, an equal partnership with indigenous Australians based on trust. Today's apology can now allow that to happen with a cleaner slate and a new resolve. We owe it to the children.

The Hon. D.W. RIDGWAY (Leader of the Opposition) (14:30): I seek leave to offer a response on behalf of the opposition.

Leave granted.

The Hon. D.W. RIDGWAY: Today marks another step in our journey towards reconciliation. It is an Australian journey. Eleven years ago, for the first time in parliamentary history, a South Australian minister said he was sorry. Today, I reaffirm the words of former Liberal premier Dean Brown, who invited the then opposition leader, Mike Rann, to second the motion in the true spirit of bipartisanship.

The state Liberals pay tribute to the struggles of many thousands of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people affected by forcible removal. We acknowledge their hardships. Today, we remember those who have been able to come home. We lament the children who could never come home. In April 1997, Australians were confronted with the stories of thousands of people whose lives had been affected by the official policies of separation of children from their families. The Bringing Them Home report changed the debate from one of policy to one about real people, real tragedies and real trauma.

I speak today to reaffirm and recognise the leadership shown by this parliament on 27 May 1997, when the Hon. Dean Brown moved:

That the South Australian parliament expresses its deep and sincere regret at the forced separation of some Aboriginal children from their families and homes which occurred prior to 1964, apologises to these Aboriginal people for these past actions and reaffirms its support for reconciliation between all Australians.

The motion was supported by all MPs. Today, together our spirit remains strong and united. This issue has been difficult for our nation as a whole to embrace. The 11-year journey began with minister Brown's apology and reached a high point today, when our federal leader shook hands across the floor of the parliament and said sorry on behalf of an entire nation.

I ask members today also to consider the future. It is imperative that we do so, to see today as not a conclusion to our journey but, rather, the beginning of a greater journey—a great journey for a reconciled nation of many cultures. As we step forward, I ask that we remember those from the indigenous community who could not join us; in the many decades of separation, the children taken from their homes who never returned; the many children who became adults who struggled with identity and belonging; and the many who have passed and their stories never told.

To understand our future, let us also understand the losses that occurred in our past. We cannot revoke the past. We cannot reinvent the past. It happened. We remember those who could never return to their home.

Liberal leader Mr Martin Hamilton-Smith had the privilege of serving our nation in the Defence Force alongside indigenous Australians (one of them was at Elder Park this morning); men and women who had the courage to serve the nation; and, in many cases, their spirit rests on foreign soil, well away from their traditional home. In some ways, the nation has often failed to serve them. We will always remember them.

Today, like 28 May 1997, is a significant day in our state's history. This parliament's apology reflected the impact of the Bringing Them Home report of the National Inquiry into the Separation of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Children from their Families. The report showed the reality of policies of past governments. Many children were forcibly removed from their families by the Australian authorities until 1969. Many people affected by the tragedy of the Stolen Generations are still alive today and live with its effects. Many were in the other chamber today. We welcome them, we thank them and we accept their invitation to join in reconciliation.

Apologising to the Stolen Generations provided our state parliament with an opportunity to recognise the wrongs within policies of past governments and to make a commitment to reconciliation. As others have said before, we have a long way to go. Health and education are at the very top of the agenda for our way forward. The apology in federal parliament today, supported by the federal Liberal opposition, marks the beginning.

Here, in South Australia, we need to do more to help our Aboriginal communities. We need to provide a means by which future generations can understand the history of indigenous culture. The South Australian Liberals have been active in our support of reconciliation and will continue to be so.

When European culture arrived in 1788, it found a happy people who lived comfortably with the land they so loved. Over time, we have had to confront many problems. Let us solve health, social and other issues. Let us educate the young children.

The new generations must be stronger, healthier and happier. The new generations should reflect the new Australia—a nation that in 2008 has learnt much from the past 220 years, a nation that sets new standards for the coming centuries. Today is a day for our children. From this day Aboriginal children should be able to grow without disadvantage. From this day non-Aboriginal children should be able to grow without any shame.

I congratulate the parliament of 1997 for its agenda-setting apology and reaffirm the motion of the time that `State Liberals reaffirm the deep and sincere regret at the forced separation of some Aboriginal children from their homes and families which occurred prior to 1964, and apologise to these Aboriginal people for the past actions.' We reaffirm our support for reconciliation between all Australians and, as a member of the South Australian parliament today, I say 'Sorry'. Today, as Leader of the Opposition in the Legislative Council, I say 'Sorry'. Let today, 13 February 2008, be remembered as a day for us to look around and learn, a day that we understand that we are all Australian, a day where we understand the importance of saying sorry and a day when we became a better Australia.

PARLIAMENTARY BUSINESS
MEMBERS
GET INVOLVED
ABOUT PARLIAMENT
VISIT
LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL
HOUSE OF ASSEMBLY
CONTACT