Legislative Council Fifty-Second Parliament, Second Session (52-2) 52 2 Parliament of South Australia Legislative Council published Bills Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation (Samfs Firefighters) Amendment Bill WORKERS REHABILITATION AND COMPENSATION (SAMFS FIREFIGHTERS) AMENDMENT BILL Second Reading Second Reading Second reading. The Hon. I.K. HUNTER Legislative Council Minister for Sustainability Minister for Water and the River Murray Minister for Aboriginal Affairs and Reconciliation The Hon. I.K. HUNTER (Minister for Sustainability, Environment and Conservation, Minister for Water and the River Murray, Minister for Aboriginal Affairs and Reconciliation) (17:00): I move: That this bill be now read a second time. I seek leave to have the second reading explanation inserted in Hansard without my reading it. Leave granted. The Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation (SAMFS Firefighters) Amendment Bill 2013 gives additional protection to firefighters exposed to higher cancer risk as a result of their work. Career firefighters are at greater risk of developing certain types of cancer due to the direct exposure to carcinogens released by combusting materials. This measure will be taken to have commenced on 1 July 2013, thereby ensuring that South Australian Metropolitan Fire Service (SAMFS) firefighters, including retained firefighters, who contract any of the 12 specified cancers after that date will, subject to qualifying periods and in the absence of proof to the contrary (but subject to other provisions of the Act), be entitled to workers compensation without having to prove that the cancer arose from their employment with SAMFS. The Commonwealth has accepted that employed firefighters are at greater risk of developing certain types of cancer, and enacted the Commonwealth Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Amendment (Fair Protection for Firefighters) Act 2011, on 6 December 2011. The establishment of this legislation was underpinned by the work undertaken by the Australian Senate Education, Employment and Workplace Relations Legislation Committee (the Senate Committee). The task of the Senate Committee was to consider the work relatedness of cancer in firefighters. It received 27 submissions from individuals and organisations, conducted public hearings, and listened to personal accounts from firefighters and their families. A finding of the Senate Committee was that the type of exposures identified in the research was more often experienced by firefighters working in urban areas, and that most operational activities undertaken in these areas related to structural and non-structural fire incidents. As reported by the Senate Committee in the Report on the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Amendment (Fair Protection for Firefighters) Bill 2011 (the Senate Committee's Report), '… studies and meta-studies conducted around the world, including in Australia in the 1980s, demonstrate that certain types of cancer are caused by the release of carcinogens from combusting materials in structure fires. These known carcinogens can include benzene, styrene, chloroform and formaldehyde, and are absorbed by firefighters through the skin or by way of inhalation.' (Senate Committee's report at paragraph 2.27) 'Most operational activities undertaken by urban firefighters are structural and non-structural fire incidents. Car fires, although technically considered non-structural, produce toxic chemicals rivalling those found in structure fires … due to the prevalence of plastic components found in cars. Unsurprisingly, even ordinary houses and household products release toxic chemicals when they burn.' (Senate Committee's report at paragraph 2.30-31). The hazards of a fire may migrate away from the scene of the fire. Evidence provided to the Senate Committee indicated that the hazards of a fire are pervasive and 'the hazards of a fire scene may be transported away from the fire scene by firefighters and the equipment they carry…' (Senate Committee's report at paragraph 1.39). The migration of the hazards of the fire may result in further hazard exposures when, for example, cleaning fire equipment or the truck back at the station. The Senate Committee concluded that when a firefighter, with a certain number of years of service, develops cancer, that cancer is most likely to be caused by occupational exposure to carcinogens. The 12 compensable primary site cancers and the applicable specified periods of employment in the Commonwealth Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Amendment (Fair Protection for Firefighters) Act 2011 are: Primary site brain cancer—5 years Primary site bladder cancer—15 years Primary site kidney cancer—15 years Primary non-Hodgkins lymphoma—15 years Primary leukaemia—5 years Primary site breast cancer—10 years Primary site testicular cancer—10 years Multiple myeloma—15 years Primary site prostate cancer—15 years Primary site ureter cancer—15 years Primary site colorectal cancer—15 years Primary site oesophageal cancer—25 years The scope of the research evidence considered by the Senate Committee about the work relatedness of cancer in firefighters, incorporated all firefighters, including volunteers. The Committee was satisfied with the scientific evidence demonstrating a link between firefighting as an occupation and the greater numbers of cancers (Senate Committee's report at paragraph 2.18). The Commonwealth legislation sponsored by the Hon. Adam Bandt (Australian Greens, member for Melbourne), and co-sponsored by the Hon. Maria Vamvakinou, (Australian Labour Party, member for Calwell), and the Hon. Russell Broadbent, (Liberal Party, member for McMillan), was given broad support on the strength of the currently available evidence considered by the Senate Committee, evidence that is primarily limited to career firefighters. When speaking about the proposed legislative amendments, the Hon. Adam Bandt stated that the legislation could be expanded to volunteer firefighters and to other groups that could demonstrate a science based case (House of Representatives, Consideration in Detail Debate at 31 October 2011, page 12,190). The proposed amendments to the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensations Act 1986 are generally consistent with those introduced by the Commonwealth and recognise the considerable effort by the Senate Committee to establish legislation based on the best currently available evidence. In the South Australian public sector, SAMFS firefighters are employed largely in urban contexts where they are exposed to structure fires. SAMFS also employs 'retained firefighters' who are employed on a part-time or as required basis in regional centres where they are called on to attend structure fires of the sort that were the subject of the Senate Committee's report. The gap in the research relevant to carcinogen exposure during firefighting activities undertaken by volunteers, and the more general limited research applicable to the Australian context, will be addressed through the Australian Firefighters' Health Study conducted by the Monash University Centre for Occupational and Environmental Health. This study is expected to be completed by September 2014 and no doubt the outcomes of that Study and any new evidence will need to be taken into consideration at that time. This Government is satisfied with the Senate Committee conclusions regarding the scientific evidence about the work relatedness of cancer in career firefighters. The Senate Committee concluded, in accordance with a number of studies which focused largely on urban based firefighters, that when a career firefighter, with a certain number of years of service, develops cancer, that cancer is most likely to be caused by occupational exposure to carcinogens. The legislative presumptions that this Bill provides will also significantly reduce the emotional and financial burden that would otherwise fall on career firefighters and their families. I commend the Bill to Members. Explanation of Clauses Explanation of Clauses Part 1—Preliminary 1—Short title This clause is formal. 2—Commencement Operation of the measure will be taken to have commenced on 1 July 2013. 3—Amendment provisions This clause is formal. Part 2—Amendment of Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1986 4—Amendment of section 31—Evidentiary provision Section 31 as amended by this clause will provide an evidentiary presumption applicable to a worker who was employed by the South Australian Metropolitan Fire Service ('SAMFS') as a firefighter. If the worker suffers an injury of a kind referred to in the first column of Schedule 2A (inserted by clause 5) and the injury occurred on or after 1 July 2013, the injury will be presumed (in the absence of proof to the contrary) to have arisen from employment by SAMFS. The presumption will apply if the worker was employed as a firefighter for the qualifying period referred to in the second column of Schedule 2A opposite the injury and, during that period, the worker was exposed to the hazards of a fire scene (including exposure to a hazard of the fire that occurred away from the scene). 5—Insertion of Schedule 2A This clause inserts a new Schedule. The Schedule lists the injuries that will be presumed under section 31 to arise from the worker's employment as a firefighter and specifies the relevant qualifying period in relation to each injury. Schedule 1—Review of amendments The Schedule requires the Minister to appoint an independent person to carry out a review concerning the operation and impact of the amendments made by the Act. The appointment is to be made as soon as possible after the fifth anniversary of the commencement of the measure and a report of the review is to be provided to the Minister within four months of the appointment. The Minister must then have copies of the report tabled before both Houses of Parliament. Debate adjourned on motion of Hon. J.S.L. Dawkins.