<!--The Official Report of Parliamentary Debates (Hansard) of the Legislative Council and the House of Assembly of the Parliament of South Australia are covered by parliamentary privilege. Republication by others is not afforded the same protection and may result in exposure to legal liability if the material is defamatory. You may copy and make use of excerpts of proceedings where (1) you attribute the Parliament as the source, (2) you assume the risk of liability if the manner of your use is defamatory, (3) you do not use the material for the purpose of advertising, satire or ridicule, or to misrepresent members of Parliament, and (4) your use of the extracts is fair, accurate and not misleading. Copyright in the Official Report of Parliamentary Debates is held by the Attorney-General of South Australia.-->
<hansard id="" tocId="" xml:lang="EN-AU" schemaVersion="4.0" xsi:noNamespaceSchemaLocation="hansard_1_0.xsd" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2007/XMLSchema-instance" xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML">
  <name>House of Assembly</name>
  <date date="2024-03-07T11:00:00+10:30" />
  <sessionName>Fifty-Fifth Parliament, First Session (55-1)</sessionName>
  <parliamentNum>55</parliamentNum>
  <sessionNum>1</sessionNum>
  <parliamentName>Parliament of South Australia</parliamentName>
  <house>House of Assembly</house>
  <venue></venue>
  <reviewStage>published</reviewStage>
  <startPage num="7243" />
  <endPage num="7307" />
  <dateModified time="2024-07-26T13:59:57+09:30" />
  <proceeding continued="true">
    <name>Question Time</name>
    <subject>
      <name>Digital Education Strategy</name>
      <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000297">
        <heading>Digital Education Strategy</heading>
      </text>
      <talker role="member" id="4343" referenceid="98bc9886f8ef4f70897848c1d1c59c00" kind="question">
        <name>The Hon. J.A.W. GARDNER</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <electorate id="">Morialta</electorate>
        <portfolios>
          <portfolio id="">
            <name>Deputy Leader of the Opposition</name>
          </portfolio>
        </portfolios>
        <questions>
          <question date="2024-03-07T00:30:00+10:30">
            <name>Digital Education Strategy</name>
          </question>
        </questions>
        <startTime time="2024-03-07T14:10:59+10:30" />
        <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000298">
          <timeStamp time="2024-03-07T14:10:59+10:30" />
          <by role="member" id="4343" referenceid="98bc9886f8ef4f70897848c1d1c59c00">The Hon. J.A.W. GARDNER (Morialta—Deputy Leader of the Opposition) (14:10):</by>  My question is to the Premier. Did the education minister advise the Premier that he had cut the budget for the laptop program by $20 million—</text>
        <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000299">
          <event kind="interjection">Members interjecting:</event>
        </text>
      </talker>
      <talker kind="speech" role="office">
        <name>The Speaker</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000300">
          <by role="office">The SPEAKER</by>:  Order!</text>
      </talker>
      <talker role="member" id="4343" referenceid="98bc9886f8ef4f70897848c1d1c59c00" kind="question" continued="true">
        <name>The Hon. J.A.W. GARDNER</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <electorate id="">Morialta</electorate>
        <portfolios>
          <portfolio id="">
            <name>Deputy Leader of the Opposition</name>
          </portfolio>
        </portfolios>
        <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000301">
          <by role="member" id="4343" referenceid="98bc9886f8ef4f70897848c1d1c59c00">The Hon. J.A.W. GARDNER:</by>  —prior to the—</text>
      </talker>
      <talker kind="speech" role="office">
        <name>The Speaker</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000302">
          <by role="office">The SPEAKER:</by>  Member for Morialta—</text>
      </talker>
      <talker role="member" id="4343" referenceid="98bc9886f8ef4f70897848c1d1c59c00" kind="question" continued="true">
        <name>The Hon. J.A.W. GARDNER</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <electorate id="">Morialta</electorate>
        <portfolios>
          <portfolio id="">
            <name>Deputy Leader of the Opposition</name>
          </portfolio>
        </portfolios>
        <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000303">
          <by role="member" id="4343" referenceid="98bc9886f8ef4f70897848c1d1c59c00">The Hon. J.A.W. GARDNER:</by>  Premier claiming credit for the program?</text>
      </talker>
      <talker kind="speech" role="office">
        <name>The Speaker</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000304">
          <by role="office">The SPEAKER:</by>  —there is a point of order which I am bound to hear under 134, and which I will do so.</text>
      </talker>
      <talker role="member" id="633" referenceid="daab39c192204b0f88930f68be57ad22">
        <name>The Hon. A. KOUTSANTONIS</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <electorate id="">West Torrens</electorate>
        <portfolios>
          <portfolio id="">
            <name>Minister for Infrastructure and Transport</name>
          </portfolio>
          <portfolio id="">
            <name>Minister for Energy and Mining</name>
          </portfolio>
        </portfolios>
        <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000305">
          <by role="member" id="633" referenceid="daab39c192204b0f88930f68be57ad22">The Hon. A. KOUTSANTONIS:</by>  Point of order: the member asked the same question to two different ministers. We speak as one.</text>
        <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000306">
          <event kind="interjection">Members interjecting:</event>
        </text>
      </talker>
      <talker kind="speech" role="office">
        <name>The Speaker</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000307">
          <by role="office">The SPEAKER</by>:  Order! We will hear the question.</text>
      </talker>
      <talker role="member" id="4343" referenceid="98bc9886f8ef4f70897848c1d1c59c00" kind="question" continued="true">
        <name>The Hon. J.A.W. GARDNER</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <electorate id="">Morialta</electorate>
        <portfolios>
          <portfolio id="">
            <name>Deputy Leader of the Opposition</name>
          </portfolio>
        </portfolios>
        <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000308">
          <by role="member" id="4343" referenceid="98bc9886f8ef4f70897848c1d1c59c00">The Hon. J.A.W. GARDNER:</by>  My question is to the Premier. Did the Minister for Education advise the Premier that he had reduced funding for the laptop program by $20 million prior to the Premier claiming credit for the program on 29 January? With your leave, sir, and that of the house, I will explain.</text>
        <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000309">
          <event kind="interjection">Members interjecting:</event>
        </text>
      </talker>
      <talker kind="speech" role="office">
        <name>The Speaker</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000310">
          <by role="office">The SPEAKER</by>:  Order! We are going to hear the question and then I will turn to the member for West Torrens. Member for Morialta, please conclude the question.</text>
      </talker>
      <talker role="member" id="4343" referenceid="98bc9886f8ef4f70897848c1d1c59c00" kind="question" continued="true">
        <name>The Hon. J.A.W. GARDNER</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <electorate id="">Morialta</electorate>
        <portfolios>
          <portfolio id="">
            <name>Deputy Leader of the Opposition</name>
          </portfolio>
        </portfolios>
        <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000311">
          <by role="member" id="4343" referenceid="98bc9886f8ef4f70897848c1d1c59c00">The Hon. J.A.W. GARDNER:</by>  On 29 January this year, the Premier issued a press release claiming:</text>
        <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000312">
          <inserted>…discounts to school fees and laptop purchases are providing South Australian families with much needed cost of living relief—with some families thousands of dollars better off.</inserted>
        </text>
        <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000313">
          <inserted>The biggest saving for some families will be through the Malinauskas Labor government's new laptop program.</inserted>
        </text>
        <text continued="true" id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000314">However, documents released to the opposition through FOI have revealed that in late 2022 the Minister for Education approved revisions to the strategy released by the former Liberal government, including delays to the rollout of devices and a $21.9 million reduction in funding for the program.</text>
        <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000315">
          <event kind="interjection">An honourable member interjecting:</event>
        </text>
      </talker>
      <talker kind="speech" role="office">
        <name>The Speaker</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000316">
          <by role="office">The SPEAKER</by>:  Order! I see that the point of order is not being maintained, so I will turn to the minister.</text>
      </talker>
      <talker role="member" id="5389" referenceid="258e99f5e8a5469db1af773d39ba5018" kind="answer">
        <name>The Hon. B.I. BOYER</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <electorate id="">Wright</electorate>
        <portfolios>
          <portfolio id="">
            <name>Minister for Education, Training and Skills</name>
          </portfolio>
        </portfolios>
        <startTime time="2024-03-07T14:12:32+10:30" />
        <page num="7266" />
        <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000317">
          <timeStamp time="2024-03-07T14:12:32+10:30" />
          <by role="member" id="5389" referenceid="258e99f5e8a5469db1af773d39ba5018">The Hon. B.I. BOYER (Wright—Minister for Education, Training and Skills) (14:12):</by>  I thank the member for Morialta for the question. I find it a bit rich that we are being lectured on cost-of-living initiatives in the education department.</text>
        <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000318">
          <event kind="interjection">Members interjecting:</event>
        </text>
      </talker>
      <talker kind="speech" role="office">
        <name>The Speaker</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000319">
          <by role="office">The SPEAKER</by>:  Order! The member for Chaffey!</text>
        <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000320">
          <event kind="interjection">Members interjecting:</event>
        </text>
      </talker>
      <talker kind="speech" role="office">
        <name>The Speaker</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000321">
          <by role="office">The SPEAKER</by>:  Order! Member for Morphett!</text>
      </talker>
      <talker role="member" id="5389" referenceid="258e99f5e8a5469db1af773d39ba5018" kind="answer" continued="true">
        <name>The Hon. B.I. BOYER</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <electorate id="">Wright</electorate>
        <portfolios>
          <portfolio id="">
            <name>Minister for Education, Training and Skills</name>
          </portfolio>
        </portfolios>
        <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000322">
          <by role="member" id="5389" referenceid="258e99f5e8a5469db1af773d39ba5018">The Hon. B.I. BOYER:</by>  So we had a rushed—</text>
        <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000323">
          <event kind="interjection">Members interjecting:</event>
        </text>
      </talker>
      <talker kind="speech" role="office">
        <name>The Speaker</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000324">
          <by role="office">The SPEAKER:</by>  The member for Morialta is warned for a second time.</text>
        <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000325">
          <event kind="interjection">Members interjecting:</event>
        </text>
      </talker>
      <talker kind="speech" role="office">
        <name>The Speaker</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000326">
          <by role="office">The SPEAKER</by>:  Order!</text>
      </talker>
      <talker role="member" id="5389" referenceid="258e99f5e8a5469db1af773d39ba5018" kind="answer" continued="true">
        <name>The Hon. B.I. BOYER</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <electorate id="">Wright</electorate>
        <portfolios>
          <portfolio id="">
            <name>Minister for Education, Training and Skills</name>
          </portfolio>
        </portfolios>
        <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000327">
          <by role="member" id="5389" referenceid="258e99f5e8a5469db1af773d39ba5018">The Hon. B.I. BOYER:</by>  We had a rushed program.</text>
        <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000328">
          <event kind="interjection">Members interjecting:</event>
        </text>
      </talker>
      <talker kind="speech" role="office">
        <name>The Speaker</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000329">
          <by role="office">The SPEAKER</by>:  Order!</text>
      </talker>
      <talker role="member" id="5389" referenceid="258e99f5e8a5469db1af773d39ba5018" kind="answer" continued="true">
        <name>The Hon. B.I. BOYER</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <electorate id="">Wright</electorate>
        <portfolios>
          <portfolio id="">
            <name>Minister for Education, Training and Skills</name>
          </portfolio>
        </portfolios>
        <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000330">
          <by role="member" id="5389" referenceid="258e99f5e8a5469db1af773d39ba5018">The Hon. B.I. BOYER:</by>  We had those opposite—</text>
      </talker>
      <talker kind="speech" role="office">
        <name>The Speaker</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000331">
          <by role="office">The SPEAKER:</by>  Minister, please be seated. If there are further interjections from the members I have already warned, they will be departing under 137A. It is impossible for me to hear the minister. The chamber wishes to hear the minister. Minister.</text>
      </talker>
      <talker role="member" id="5389" referenceid="258e99f5e8a5469db1af773d39ba5018" kind="answer" continued="true">
        <name>The Hon. B.I. BOYER</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <electorate id="">Wright</electorate>
        <portfolios>
          <portfolio id="">
            <name>Minister for Education, Training and Skills</name>
          </portfolio>
        </portfolios>
        <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000332">
          <by role="member" id="5389" referenceid="258e99f5e8a5469db1af773d39ba5018">The Hon. B.I. BOYER:</by>  Thank you, Mr Speaker. What we had from those opposite was a pretty rushed policy towards the end of their four years in government, late to the party on cost-of-living issues as per usual from the South Australian Liberal Party.</text>
        <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000333">
          <event kind="interjection">Members interjecting:</event>
        </text>
      </talker>
      <talker kind="speech" role="office">
        <name>The Speaker</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000334">
          <by role="office">The SPEAKER</by>:  Order!</text>
      </talker>
      <talker role="member" id="5389" referenceid="258e99f5e8a5469db1af773d39ba5018" kind="answer" continued="true">
        <name>The Hon. B.I. BOYER</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <electorate id="">Wright</electorate>
        <portfolios>
          <portfolio id="">
            <name>Minister for Education, Training and Skills</name>
          </portfolio>
        </portfolios>
        <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000335">
          <by role="member" id="5389" referenceid="258e99f5e8a5469db1af773d39ba5018">The Hon. B.I. BOYER:</by>  No-one would ever accuse those opposite of being in touch. Upon coming to government, of course, we made a series of very significant election commitments around education. One of those was, of course, cost of living as well. We matched those opposite when they made a commitment around $100 off the materials and services charge. We have now extended that beyond the commitment that was made by the Liberal Party.</text>
        <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000336">
          <event kind="interjection">Members interjecting:</event>
        </text>
      </talker>
      <talker kind="speech" role="office">
        <name>The Speaker</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000337">
          <by role="office">The SPEAKER</by>:  Order!</text>
      </talker>
      <talker role="member" id="5389" referenceid="258e99f5e8a5469db1af773d39ba5018" kind="answer" continued="true">
        <name>The Hon. B.I. BOYER</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <electorate id="">Wright</electorate>
        <portfolios>
          <portfolio id="">
            <name>Minister for Education, Training and Skills</name>
          </portfolio>
        </portfolios>
        <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000338">
          <by role="member" id="5389" referenceid="258e99f5e8a5469db1af773d39ba5018">The Hon. B.I. BOYER:</by>  We have delivered it for a third time, and now on top of that comes a digital strategy which by 2026 will see every child who is eligible for the School Card in the public education system get their laptop for free. So on that basis—</text>
        <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000339">
          <event kind="interjection">Members interjecting:</event>
        </text>
      </talker>
      <talker kind="speech" role="office">
        <name>The Speaker</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000340">
          <by role="office">The SPEAKER</by>:  Order!</text>
      </talker>
      <talker role="member" id="5389" referenceid="258e99f5e8a5469db1af773d39ba5018" kind="answer" continued="true">
        <name>The Hon. B.I. BOYER</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <electorate id="">Wright</electorate>
        <portfolios>
          <portfolio id="">
            <name>Minister for Education, Training and Skills</name>
          </portfolio>
        </portfolios>
        <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000341">
          <by role="member" id="5389" referenceid="258e99f5e8a5469db1af773d39ba5018">The Hon. B.I. BOYER:</by>  As I said in the answer to the member for Morialta's earlier question—and I know the member for Port Adelaide will remember this about a very significant digital device strategy which was committed to by the then Liberal government in 2018 and the first thing that was done—</text>
        <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000342">
          <event kind="interjection">Members interjecting:</event>
        </text>
      </talker>
      <talker kind="speech" role="office">
        <name>The Speaker</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000343">
          <by role="office">The SPEAKER:</by>  Member for Morialta!</text>
      </talker>
      <talker role="member" id="5389" referenceid="258e99f5e8a5469db1af773d39ba5018" kind="answer" continued="true">
        <name>The Hon. B.I. BOYER</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <electorate id="">Wright</electorate>
        <portfolios>
          <portfolio id="">
            <name>Minister for Education, Training and Skills</name>
          </portfolio>
        </portfolios>
        <page num="7267" />
        <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000344">
          <by role="member" id="5389" referenceid="258e99f5e8a5469db1af773d39ba5018">The Hon. B.I. BOYER:</by>  They say it wasn't a strategy, but it had money behind it. It had real money behind it—</text>
        <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000345">
          <event kind="interjection">Members interjecting:</event>
        </text>
      </talker>
      <talker kind="speech" role="office">
        <name>The Speaker</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000346">
          <by role="office">The SPEAKER:</by>  Order!</text>
      </talker>
      <talker role="member" id="5389" referenceid="258e99f5e8a5469db1af773d39ba5018" kind="answer" continued="true">
        <name>The Hon. B.I. BOYER</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <electorate id="">Wright</electorate>
        <portfolios>
          <portfolio id="">
            <name>Minister for Education, Training and Skills</name>
          </portfolio>
        </portfolios>
        <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000347">
          <by role="member" id="5389" referenceid="258e99f5e8a5469db1af773d39ba5018">The Hon. B.I. BOYER:</by>  —and one of the first things they did was cut it, so I won't be lectured to by those opposite when one of the first things they did when they came to government was cut the initiative made by the member for Port Adelaide.</text>
        <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000348">
          <event kind="interjection">Members interjecting:</event>
        </text>
      </talker>
      <talker kind="speech" role="office">
        <name>The Speaker</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000349">
          <by role="office">The SPEAKER:</by>  Order! The member for Morphett is warned.</text>
      </talker>
      <talker role="member" id="5389" referenceid="258e99f5e8a5469db1af773d39ba5018" kind="answer" continued="true">
        <name>The Hon. B.I. BOYER</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <electorate id="">Wright</electorate>
        <portfolios>
          <portfolio id="">
            <name>Minister for Education, Training and Skills</name>
          </portfolio>
        </portfolios>
        <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000350">
          <by role="member" id="5389" referenceid="258e99f5e8a5469db1af773d39ba5018">The Hon. B.I. BOYER:</by>  Hypocrisy writ large.</text>
        <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000351">
          <event kind="interjection">Members interjecting:</event>
        </text>
      </talker>
      <talker kind="speech" role="office">
        <name>The Speaker</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000352">
          <by role="office">The SPEAKER:</by>  Order! Minister, please be seated. The member for Morphett, who persistently interjects, will depart under 137A for the remainder of question time. The member for Florey is not far behind.</text>
        <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000353">
          <event>The honourable member for Morphett having withdrawn from the chamber:</event>
        </text>
      </talker>
      <talker kind="speech" role="office">
        <name>The Speaker</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="20240307e245cb7b07ec482990000354">
          <by role="office">The SPEAKER:</by>  Minister, you have the call—you have concluded your answer? Very well. I turn to the opposition.</text>
      </talker>
    </subject>
  </proceeding>
</hansard>