<!--The Official Report of Parliamentary Debates (Hansard) of the Legislative Council and the House of Assembly of the Parliament of South Australia are covered by parliamentary privilege. Republication by others is not afforded the same protection and may result in exposure to legal liability if the material is defamatory. You may copy and make use of excerpts of proceedings where (1) you attribute the Parliament as the source, (2) you assume the risk of liability if the manner of your use is defamatory, (3) you do not use the material for the purpose of advertising, satire or ridicule, or to misrepresent members of Parliament, and (4) your use of the extracts is fair, accurate and not misleading. Copyright in the Official Report of Parliamentary Debates is held by the Attorney-General of South Australia.-->
<hansard id="" tocId="" xml:lang="EN-AU" schemaVersion="1.0" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" xmlns:xml="http://www.w3.org/XML/1998/namespace" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2007/XMLSchema-instance" xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" xsi:noNamespaceSchemaLocation="hansard_1_0.xsd">
  <name>House of Assembly</name>
  <date date="2021-09-23" />
  <sessionName>Fifty-Fourth Parliament, Second Session (54-2)</sessionName>
  <parliamentNum>54</parliamentNum>
  <sessionNum>2</sessionNum>
  <parliamentName>Parliament of South Australia</parliamentName>
  <house>House of Assembly</house>
  <venue></venue>
  <reviewStage>published</reviewStage>
  <startPage num="7398" />
  <endPage num="7814" />
  <dateModified time="2022-08-06T14:30:00+00:00" />
  <proceeding continued="true">
    <name>Question Time</name>
    <subject>
      <name>Facebook Posts</name>
      <text id="202109230396b9fe9cd54816b0000447">
        <heading>Facebook Posts</heading>
      </text>
      <talker role="member" id="5084" kind="question">
        <name>Mr MALINAUSKAS</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <electorate id="">Croydon</electorate>
        <portfolios>
          <portfolio id="">
            <name>Leader of the Opposition</name>
          </portfolio>
        </portfolios>
        <questions>
          <question date="2021-09-23">
            <name>Facebook Posts</name>
          </question>
        </questions>
        <startTime time="2021-09-23T14:28:17" />
        <text id="202109230396b9fe9cd54816b0000448">
          <timeStamp time="2021-09-23T14:28:17" />
          <by role="member" id="5084">Mr MALINAUSKAS (Croydon—Leader of the Opposition) (14:28):</by>  I will ask the Premier another question.</text>
        <text id="202109230396b9fe9cd54816b0000449">
          <event kind="interjection">Members interjecting:</event>
        </text>
      </talker>
      <talker kind="speech" role="office">
        <name>The Speaker</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="202109230396b9fe9cd54816b0000450">
          <by role="office">The SPEAKER:</by>  The leader has the call.</text>
      </talker>
      <talker role="member" id="5084" kind="question" continued="true">
        <name>Mr MALINAUSKAS</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="202109230396b9fe9cd54816b0000451">
          <by role="member" id="5084">Mr MALINAUSKAS:</by>  My question is to the Premier. When a South Australian goes onto your Facebook page—</text>
        <text id="202109230396b9fe9cd54816b0000452">
          <event kind="interjection">Members interjecting:</event>
        </text>
      </talker>
      <talker role="member" id="5084" kind="question" continued="true">
        <name>Mr MALINAUSKAS</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="202109230396b9fe9cd54816b0000453">
          <by role="member" id="5084">Mr MALINAUSKAS:</by>  —on the Premier's Facebook—</text>
        <text id="202109230396b9fe9cd54816b0000454">
          <event kind="interjection">Members interjecting:</event>
        </text>
      </talker>
      <talker kind="speech" role="office">
        <name>The Speaker</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="202109230396b9fe9cd54816b0000455">
          <by role="office">The SPEAKER:</by>  Members on my right!</text>
        <text id="202109230396b9fe9cd54816b0000456">
          <event kind="interjection">Members interjecting:</event>
        </text>
      </talker>
      <talker kind="speech" role="office">
        <name>The Speaker</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="202109230396b9fe9cd54816b0000457">
          <by role="office">The SPEAKER:</by>  Members on my left!</text>
        <text id="202109230396b9fe9cd54816b0000458">
          <event kind="interjection">Members interjecting:</event>
        </text>
      </talker>
      <talker kind="speech" role="office">
        <name>The Speaker</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="202109230396b9fe9cd54816b0000459">
          <by role="office">The SPEAKER:</by>  Order! The Premier is called to order. The leader has the call. The leader is entitled to be heard in silence. Members on my left!</text>
      </talker>
      <talker role="member" id="5084" kind="question" continued="true">
        <name>Mr MALINAUSKAS</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="202109230396b9fe9cd54816b0000460">
          <by role="member" id="5084">Mr MALINAUSKAS:</by>  My question is to the Premier. When a South Australian goes on the Premier's official Facebook page and signs up to the Premier's official Facebook page, where does the information regarding that South Australian go, to the South Australian Liberal Party or the South Australian government?</text>
      </talker>
      <talker role="member" id="4338" kind="answer">
        <name>The Hon. S.S. MARSHALL</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <electorate id="">Dunstan</electorate>
        <portfolios>
          <portfolio id="">
            <name>Premier</name>
          </portfolio>
        </portfolios>
        <startTime time="2021-09-23T14:29:16" />
        <text id="202109230396b9fe9cd54816b0000461">
          <timeStamp time="2021-09-23T14:29:16" />
          <by role="member" id="4338">The Hon. S.S. MARSHALL (Dunstan—Premier) (14:29):</by>  The Leader of the Opposition is getting confused. I have had a Facebook account for it must be more than a decade. It's a Steven Marshall account. Yes, it does say 'Premier of South Australia'. It is not an official government Facebook site, an official government website. I happen to be the Premier of South Australia.</text>
        <text id="202109230396b9fe9cd54816b0000462">
          <event kind="interjection">Members interjecting:</event>
        </text>
      </talker>
      <talker kind="speech" role="office">
        <name>The Speaker</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="202109230396b9fe9cd54816b0000463">
          <by role="office">The SPEAKER</by>:  Order!</text>
      </talker>
      <talker role="member" id="4338" kind="answer" continued="true">
        <name>The Hon. S.S. MARSHALL</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="202109230396b9fe9cd54816b0000464">
          <by role="member" id="4338">The Hon. S.S. MARSHALL:</by>  It's a position of great privilege. It's an honour to serve in this role. I will use every single method possible to promote our key COVID messages to the people of South Australia. The Leader of the Opposition is complaining about this today. He is coming in here saying, 'How dare the Liberal Party use Liberal Party dollars to promote the COVID message?' But he sits idly by—</text>
      </talker>
      <talker kind="speech" role="office">
        <name>The Speaker</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="202109230396b9fe9cd54816b0000465">
          <by role="office">The SPEAKER</by>:  Order! The Premier will resume his seat. The leader rises on a point of order.</text>
      </talker>
      <talker role="member" id="5084">
        <name>Mr MALINAUSKAS</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="202109230396b9fe9cd54816b0000466">
          <by role="member" id="5084">Mr MALINAUSKAS:</by>  Standing order 98: this is clearly debate. The Premier is seeking to—</text>
        <text id="202109230396b9fe9cd54816b0000467">
          <event kind="interjection">Members interjecting:</event>
        </text>
      </talker>
      <talker kind="speech" role="office">
        <name>The Speaker</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="202109230396b9fe9cd54816b0000468">
          <by role="office">The SPEAKER:</by>  Order, members on my right!</text>
      </talker>
      <talker role="member" id="5084">
        <name>Mr MALINAUSKAS</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <page num="7704" />
        <text id="202109230396b9fe9cd54816b0000469">
          <by role="member" id="5084">Mr MALINAUSKAS:</by>  The Premier is seeking to characterise the line of questioning and making references to the Labor Party. We are simply asking: where does the information go? Is it going to the Liberal Party, or is it going to the government?</text>
        <text id="202109230396b9fe9cd54816b0000470">
          <event kind="interjection">Members interjecting:</event>
        </text>
      </talker>
      <talker kind="speech" role="office">
        <name>The Speaker</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="202109230396b9fe9cd54816b0000471">
          <by role="office">The SPEAKER</by>:  Order! The member for King is called to order. The Premier, in answering the question—and I have noted the question—is addressing the substance of the question. The Premier is in order and the Premier has the call. I don't uphold the point of order. The Premier has the call.</text>
      </talker>
      <talker role="member" id="4338" kind="answer" continued="true">
        <name>The Hon. S.S. MARSHALL</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="202109230396b9fe9cd54816b0000472">
          <by role="member" id="4338">The Hon. S.S. MARSHALL:</by>  It seems an extraordinary line of questioning, but nothing is extraordinary in this place anymore. The question right back to the Leader of the Opposition is: when people like his page—and, let's face it, he's been using taxpayer dollars to promote all sorts of political Labor Party advertisements in recent times, including radio advertisements—where does that data go? Where does that data go?</text>
        <text id="202109230396b9fe9cd54816b0000473">
          <event kind="interjection">Members interjecting:</event>
        </text>
      </talker>
      <talker kind="speech" role="office">
        <name>The Speaker</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="202109230396b9fe9cd54816b0000474">
          <by role="office">The SPEAKER</by>:  Order!</text>
      </talker>
      <talker role="member" id="4338" kind="answer" continued="true">
        <name>The Hon. S.S. MARSHALL</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="202109230396b9fe9cd54816b0000475">
          <by role="member" id="4338">The Hon. S.S. MARSHALL:</by>  When somebody likes the member from West Torrens's Facebook site, where does that data go? What sinister means is the member for West Torrens using with the data that he has collected because people like his page?</text>
        <text id="202109230396b9fe9cd54816b0000476">
          <event kind="interjection">Members interjecting:</event>
        </text>
      </talker>
      <talker kind="speech" role="office">
        <name>The Speaker</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="202109230396b9fe9cd54816b0000477">
          <by role="office">The SPEAKER:</by>  The member for Playford is warned.</text>
      </talker>
      <talker role="member" id="4338" kind="answer" continued="true">
        <name>The Hon. S.S. MARSHALL</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="202109230396b9fe9cd54816b0000478">
          <by role="member" id="4338">The Hon. S.S. MARSHALL:</by>  As I have said right from day one, this is very clearly Liberal Party dollars being used to promote the simple messages that we want to convey to the people of South Australia. I think it's great that the Liberal Party want to do this. I think it is outstanding that the Liberal Party want to join in. Clearly, those opposite are used to what was going on—which was rife when they were in government—which is using taxpayer dollars to advance their cause. This by contrast—</text>
        <text id="202109230396b9fe9cd54816b0000479">
          <event kind="interjection">Members interjecting:</event>
        </text>
      </talker>
      <talker role="member" id="4338" kind="answer" continued="true">
        <name>The Hon. S.S. MARSHALL</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="202109230396b9fe9cd54816b0000480">
          <by role="member" id="4338">The Hon. S.S. MARSHALL:</by>  Yes, absolutely! And that's why when we came to government we had to completely rewrite—</text>
        <text id="202109230396b9fe9cd54816b0000481">
          <event kind="interjection">Members interjecting:</event>
        </text>
      </talker>
      <talker kind="speech" role="office">
        <name>The Speaker</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="202109230396b9fe9cd54816b0000482">
          <by role="office">The SPEAKER:</by>  The leader!</text>
      </talker>
      <talker role="member" id="4338" kind="answer" continued="true">
        <name>The Hon. S.S. MARSHALL</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="202109230396b9fe9cd54816b0000483">
          <by role="member" id="4338">The Hon. S.S. MARSHALL:</by>  —the way that we actually spent taxpayers dollars when it came to taxpayer-funded advertising campaigns because, quite frankly—</text>
        <text id="202109230396b9fe9cd54816b0000484">
          <event kind="interjection">Members interjecting:</event>
        </text>
      </talker>
      <talker kind="speech" role="office">
        <name>The Speaker</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="202109230396b9fe9cd54816b0000485">
          <by role="office">The SPEAKER:</by>  Member for Ramsay!</text>
      </talker>
      <talker role="member" id="4338" kind="answer" continued="true">
        <name>The Hon. S.S. MARSHALL</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="202109230396b9fe9cd54816b0000486">
          <by role="member" id="4338">The Hon. S.S. MARSHALL:</by>  —people were a bit sick of seeing Labor Party politicians' faces on their television set—paid for by the taxpayers of South Australia—immediately up to an election. That's what they were sick of and that's what we unwound on coming to government. But we still do have some significant expenditure in terms of our advertising, and I think most people appreciate we've got a very important message to get across to the people of South Australia.</text>
        <text id="202109230396b9fe9cd54816b0000487">With regard to the line of questioning that the Leader of the Opposition has gone down today, I cannot be any clearer: the Liberal Party have been using their own money, the Liberal Party's money, to promote to the people of South Australia their desire for all South Australians to know about COVID, the state's response to COVID, the things that we can do to protect our state and, in particular, having a successful vaccination rollout in this state. It's going well, and I thank the Liberal Party for participating in informing the people of South Australia about that.</text>
        <page num="7705" />
        <text id="202109230396b9fe9cd54816b0000488">This does contrast—and it's important for people to understand the contrast—between how the Liberal Party is spending money on a positive campaign to promote health and keep our state safe in our economy strong versus the Labor Party, which have taken taxpayer dollars through the Leader of the Opposition's office, put ads on radio, and they have done so for what reason? To promote Labor Party policies, not public health messages—Labor Party policies. That's the same old Labor. Shame on them!</text>
        <text id="202109230396b9fe9cd54816b0000489">
          <event kind="interjection">Members interjecting:</event>
        </text>
      </talker>
      <talker kind="speech" role="office">
        <name>The Speaker</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="202109230396b9fe9cd54816b0000490">
          <by role="office">The SPEAKER:</by>  Order! Before I call the leader, the member for Playford is warned for a second time, the member for Ramsay is called to order, the member for Lee is called to order and the Minister for Innovation and Skills is warned. I call to order the Minister for Energy and Mining and I call to order the deputy leader and the leader.</text>
      </talker>
    </subject>
  </proceeding>
</hansard>