<!--The Official Report of Parliamentary Debates (Hansard) of the Legislative Council and the House of Assembly of the Parliament of South Australia are covered by parliamentary privilege. Republication by others is not afforded the same protection and may result in exposure to legal liability if the material is defamatory. You may copy and make use of excerpts of proceedings where (1) you attribute the Parliament as the source, (2) you assume the risk of liability if the manner of your use is defamatory, (3) you do not use the material for the purpose of advertising, satire or ridicule, or to misrepresent members of Parliament, and (4) your use of the extracts is fair, accurate and not misleading. Copyright in the Official Report of Parliamentary Debates is held by the Attorney-General of South Australia.-->
<hansard id="" tocId="" xml:lang="EN-AU" schemaVersion="1.0" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" xmlns:xml="http://www.w3.org/XML/1998/namespace" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2007/XMLSchema-instance" xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" xsi:noNamespaceSchemaLocation="hansard_1_0.xsd">
  <name>House of Assembly</name>
  <date date="2021-03-03" />
  <sessionName>Fifty-Fourth Parliament, Second Session (54-2)</sessionName>
  <parliamentNum>54</parliamentNum>
  <sessionNum>2</sessionNum>
  <parliamentName>Parliament of South Australia</parliamentName>
  <house>House of Assembly</house>
  <venue></venue>
  <reviewStage>published</reviewStage>
  <startPage num="4382" />
  <endPage num="4784" />
  <dateModified time="2022-08-06T14:30:00+00:00" />
  <proceeding continued="true">
    <name>Question Time</name>
    <subject>
      <name>State Economy</name>
      <page num="4412" />
      <text id="202103030e2bfbfad2fe437b80000401">
        <heading>State Economy</heading>
      </text>
      <talker role="member" id="5084" kind="question">
        <name>Mr MALINAUSKAS</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <electorate id="">Croydon</electorate>
        <portfolios>
          <portfolio id="">
            <name>Leader of the Opposition</name>
          </portfolio>
        </portfolios>
        <questions>
          <question date="2021-03-03">
            <name>State Economy</name>
          </question>
        </questions>
        <startTime time="2021-03-03T14:20:12" />
        <text id="202103030e2bfbfad2fe437b80000402">
          <timeStamp time="2021-03-03T14:20:12" />
          <by role="member" id="5084">Mr MALINAUSKAS (Croydon—Leader of the Opposition) (14:20):</by>  My supplementary question is to the Premier. Does the Premier expect the people of this state to believe that having the lowest participation rate on the mainland while having the highest unemployment rate in the country is good news?</text>
      </talker>
      <talker role="member" id="4338" kind="answer">
        <name>The Hon. S.S. MARSHALL</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <electorate id="">Dunstan</electorate>
        <portfolios>
          <portfolio id="">
            <name>Premier</name>
          </portfolio>
        </portfolios>
        <questions>
          <question date="2021-03-03">
            <name>State Economy</name>
          </question>
        </questions>
        <startTime time="2021-03-03T14:20:39" />
        <text id="202103030e2bfbfad2fe437b80000403">
          <timeStamp time="2021-03-03T14:20:39" />
          <by role="member" id="4338">The Hon. S.S. MARSHALL (Dunstan—Premier) (14:20):</by>  I hope these questions keep coming thick and fast because it gives me an opportunity to talk about how well this state is doing. We know that the ABS statistics move around. We know that.</text>
        <text id="202103030e2bfbfad2fe437b80000404">
          <event kind="interjection">Members interjecting:</event>
        </text>
      </talker>
      <talker kind="speech" role="office">
        <name>The Speaker</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="202103030e2bfbfad2fe437b80000405">
          <by role="office">The SPEAKER</by>:  Order!</text>
      </talker>
      <talker role="member" id="4338" kind="answer" continued="true">
        <name>The Hon. S.S. MARSHALL</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="202103030e2bfbfad2fe437b80000406">
          <by role="member" id="4338">The Hon. S.S. MARSHALL:</by>  The ABS give a warning about the volatility with regard to the figures at the moment. In fact, they are not even providing the trend data at the moment. If they actually took five minutes—</text>
        <text id="202103030e2bfbfad2fe437b80000407">
          <event kind="interjection">Members interjecting:</event>
        </text>
      </talker>
      <talker kind="speech" role="office">
        <name>The Speaker</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="202103030e2bfbfad2fe437b80000408">
          <by role="office">The SPEAKER:</by>  Order, members on my left!</text>
      </talker>
      <talker role="member" id="4338" kind="answer" continued="true">
        <name>The Hon. S.S. MARSHALL</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="202103030e2bfbfad2fe437b80000409">
          <by role="member" id="4338">The Hon. S.S. MARSHALL:</by>  —to read what is actually—</text>
        <text id="202103030e2bfbfad2fe437b80000410">
          <event kind="interjection" role="member" id="4842">The Hon. S.C. Mullighan interjecting:</event>
        </text>
      </talker>
      <talker kind="speech" role="office">
        <name>The Speaker</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="202103030e2bfbfad2fe437b80000411">
          <by role="office">The SPEAKER:</by>  Member for Lee!</text>
      </talker>
      <talker role="member" id="4338" kind="answer" continued="true">
        <name>The Hon. S.S. MARSHALL</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <page num="4740" />
        <text id="202103030e2bfbfad2fe437b80000412">
          <by role="member" id="4338">The Hon. S.S. MARSHALL:</by>  —going on with those statistics, they would know a lot more about exactly and precisely what is happening. But a very good indicator of what is happening in terms of jobs and in terms of wages comes out on a fortnightly basis from the ABS with the national payroll data. This is all the pay-as-you-go data from the entire country. So instead of just a survey of 1,700 people with 400 people being added on and 400 people being taken off each year and then extrapolating that across $1.7 million, you've got every single pay-as-you-go piece of data in the state, in the nation, delivered every two weeks. What does that highly accurate data show? I can't believe they haven't raised this. I can't believe—</text>
        <text id="202103030e2bfbfad2fe437b80000413">
          <event kind="interjection" role="member" id="4842">The Hon. S.C. Mullighan interjecting:</event>
        </text>
      </talker>
      <talker kind="speech" role="office">
        <name>The Speaker</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="202103030e2bfbfad2fe437b80000414">
          <by role="office">The SPEAKER:</by>  Member for Lee!</text>
      </talker>
      <talker role="member" id="4338" kind="answer" continued="true">
        <name>The Hon. S.S. MARSHALL</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="202103030e2bfbfad2fe437b80000415">
          <by role="member" id="4338">The Hon. S.S. MARSHALL:</by>  —they haven't come in here to congratulate the people of South Australia, the businesses in South Australia and, indeed, a supportive government for delivering what we see in these statistics. The figures are out today. I can't believe the—</text>
        <text id="202103030e2bfbfad2fe437b80000416">
          <event kind="interjection" role="member" id="633">The Hon. A. Koutsantonis interjecting:</event>
        </text>
      </talker>
      <talker kind="speech" role="office">
        <name>The Speaker</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="202103030e2bfbfad2fe437b80000417">
          <by role="office">The SPEAKER:</by>  Member for West Torrens!</text>
      </talker>
      <talker role="member" id="4338" kind="answer" continued="true">
        <name>The Hon. S.S. MARSHALL</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="202103030e2bfbfad2fe437b80000418">
          <by role="member" id="4338">The Hon. S.S. MARSHALL:</by>  —current leader has asked this question. Payroll jobs in South Australia for the last two weeks—are you ready for this?—grew 0.5 per cent against the nation of only 0.1 per cent, so five times faster than the nation. In terms of payroll wages—</text>
        <text id="202103030e2bfbfad2fe437b80000419">
          <event kind="interjection" role="member" id="4847">Mr Knoll interjecting:</event>
        </text>
      </talker>
      <talker kind="speech" role="office">
        <name>The Speaker</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="202103030e2bfbfad2fe437b80000420">
          <by role="office">The SPEAKER:</by>  Order, the member for Schubert!</text>
      </talker>
      <talker role="member" id="4338" kind="answer" continued="true">
        <name>The Hon. S.S. MARSHALL</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="202103030e2bfbfad2fe437b80000421">
          <by role="member" id="4338">The Hon. S.S. MARSHALL:</by>  —for the two-week period, up a whopping 2.4 per cent.</text>
        <text id="202103030e2bfbfad2fe437b80000422">
          <event kind="interjection">Members interjecting:</event>
        </text>
      </talker>
      <talker kind="speech" role="office">
        <name>The Speaker</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="202103030e2bfbfad2fe437b80000423">
          <by role="office">The SPEAKER:</by>  Order!</text>
      </talker>
      <talker role="member" id="4338" kind="answer" continued="true">
        <name>The Hon. S.S. MARSHALL</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="202103030e2bfbfad2fe437b80000424">
          <by role="member" id="4338">The Hon. S.S. MARSHALL:</by>  Some might say, 'Well, look, that's a statistical anomaly,' so why don't we go back and look at the statistics from before the coronavirus to right about now, the last two weeks. Let's see what it shows. Are you ready?</text>
        <text id="202103030e2bfbfad2fe437b80000425">
          <event kind="interjection">Members interjecting:</event>
        </text>
      </talker>
      <talker role="member" id="4338" kind="answer" continued="true">
        <name>The Hon. S.S. MARSHALL</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="202103030e2bfbfad2fe437b80000426">
          <by role="member" id="4338">The Hon. S.S. MARSHALL:</by>  Are you excited?</text>
        <text id="202103030e2bfbfad2fe437b80000427">
          <event kind="interjection">Members interjecting:</event>
        </text>
      </talker>
      <talker role="member" id="4338" kind="answer" continued="true">
        <name>The Hon. S.S. MARSHALL</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="202103030e2bfbfad2fe437b80000428">
          <by role="member" id="4338">The Hon. S.S. MARSHALL:</by>  I'm a little bit excited too.</text>
      </talker>
      <talker kind="speech" role="office">
        <name>The Speaker</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="202103030e2bfbfad2fe437b80000429">
          <by role="office">The SPEAKER:</by>  Order, the minister!</text>
      </talker>
      <talker role="member" id="4338" kind="answer" continued="true">
        <name>The Hon. S.S. MARSHALL</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="202103030e2bfbfad2fe437b80000430">
          <by role="member" id="4338">The Hon. S.S. MARSHALL:</by>  Let's take a look at this: South Australia has had the largest jobs growth of all the states. We've got more people, 0.7 of a per cent increase—0.7 of a per cent increase.</text>
        <text id="202103030e2bfbfad2fe437b80000431">
          <event kind="interjection">Members interjecting:</event>
        </text>
      </talker>
      <talker kind="speech" role="office">
        <name>The Speaker</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="202103030e2bfbfad2fe437b80000432">
          <by role="office">The SPEAKER</by>:  Order!</text>
      </talker>
      <talker role="member" id="4338" kind="answer" continued="true">
        <name>The Hon. S.S. MARSHALL</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="202103030e2bfbfad2fe437b80000433">
          <by role="member" id="4338">The Hon. S.S. MARSHALL:</by>  We've also, importantly—</text>
        <text id="202103030e2bfbfad2fe437b80000434">
          <event kind="interjection" role="member" id="5084">Mr Malinauskas interjecting:</event>
        </text>
      </talker>
      <talker kind="speech" role="office">
        <name>The Speaker</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="202103030e2bfbfad2fe437b80000435">
          <by role="office">The SPEAKER:</by>  Order, the leader!</text>
      </talker>
      <talker role="member" id="4338" kind="answer" continued="true">
        <name>The Hon. S.S. MARSHALL</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="202103030e2bfbfad2fe437b80000436">
          <by role="member" id="4338">The Hon. S.S. MARSHALL:</by>  You can't just look at jobs, because many people have lost—</text>
        <text id="202103030e2bfbfad2fe437b80000437">
          <event kind="interjection" role="member" id="5084">Mr Malinauskas interjecting:</event>
        </text>
      </talker>
      <talker kind="speech" role="office">
        <name>The Speaker</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="202103030e2bfbfad2fe437b80000438">
          <by role="office">The SPEAKER:</by>  The leader will cease interjecting.</text>
      </talker>
      <talker role="member" id="4338" kind="answer" continued="true">
        <name>The Hon. S.S. MARSHALL</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <page num="4741" />
        <text id="202103030e2bfbfad2fe437b80000439">
          <by role="member" id="4338">The Hon. S.S. MARSHALL:</by>  Many people have lost hours. They might have kept their jobs but they have had reduced hours, so it is also important to look at whether there has been an increase or a decrease in total wages paid for that period. I am just going to refer to my notes here: we've also had the highest total wages growth of all states—1.5 per cent up.</text>
        <text id="202103030e2bfbfad2fe437b80000440">This is what happens when you put the people of South Australia first. This is what happens when you don't talk down the state. This is what happens when you manage a pandemic and you actually manage the health crisis—you get an economic benefit as well. We've already seen consumer confidence is up, business confidence is up, investor confidence is up and, as these ABS statistics show, so are jobs and wages.</text>
        <text id="202103030e2bfbfad2fe437b80000441">My strong advice to my friends opposite is for them to stop talking down our great state. The people of South Australia have worked very, very hard over the last 12 months and they have a mighty challenge in front of them, another 12 months to roll out that vaccine. But let me say, they have done a great job. It's a pity that those opposite can't get on board.</text>
      </talker>
      <talker kind="speech" role="office">
        <name>The Speaker</name>
        <house>House of Assembly</house>
        <text id="202103030e2bfbfad2fe437b80000442">
          <by role="office">The SPEAKER</by>:  Order! Before I call the member for Newland, I warn the member for Schubert, I call to order the member for Hammond, I call to order the member for Wright, I warn the member for Lee and I warn the member for West Torrens for a second time. </text>
      </talker>
    </subject>
  </proceeding>
</hansard>